Having a humanitarian love for someone does not exclude recognizing that person's faults or guilt. Take my brother-in-law (please take him! ta-doosh ) for example. I love him as a person, but because of his drug-induced beating of his step-son, he deserves conviction, jail time, and psychiatric treatment.
The treatment would be for his own good. Torture is never for someone's own good. Eternal torture cannot be justified by love, only by hatred. You are hateful.