Karma reasons for concrete message



    Posts: 2196
  • Darwins +288/-0

great point but it doesn't apply... I am forwarding that God answers prayers in an advisory standpoint in some cadoesnt do things independently to affect the world... Like to sat a farmers prayer for rain would fall to death ears

That's fine to say, but you still haven't distinguished your god's answers from someone who claims that a rock 'advises' them.  You'll need to do that before it can be taken seriously.  And again, if you can't, you need to really think it through.  That voice in your head giving you advice could just be you.

It's interesting to note that devising a test for the person who believes that a rock gives them special advice has the exact same difficulties as devising a test for the person who believes that God gives them advice.  Does that tell you anything? 
Changed Change Reason Date
Graybeard The rock analogy January 01, 2013, 01:07:51 PM