I picked up that clip that you could not view from another source.
Please see if you can load it then you will know as much as I do right from the experts.
Thanks! That link appears to work, though I'm in no position to view it right now. Will do so later on.
There is nothing repeatable or verifiable for claims of Jesus but are for what we are talking about here.
When scientists make public statements they are under close scrutiny. I believe that Sudbury scientist because his career is on the line if he fudged any data and if his experiment cannot be replicated using his methods by other scientists.
They have peer revue. Theologians have nothing like it.
And perhaps the video will answer the following, but I thought I'd ask them now while I'm thinking about them:
1) There are
repeatable or verifiable claims for what we're talking about? And by repeatable, I mean experiments that have actually been independently repeated
. And again, haven't watched the video yet so I may be speaking out of turn here, but I would have expected your claim here to be followed by some examples
(peer reviewed journals, other instances of these tests being repeated and verified) of repeatability.
2) Stanley Pons and Martin Fleischmann also made public statements, and I suspect their careers were also on the line. I don't think they intentionally fudged their data, but they did
, innocuously or otherwise, screw up their experiment
so the claims they made that they thought were true
turned out to be false
, revealed by attempted replication of their experiment and results. Basically, I'm sure the Sudbury scientist wants
to be honest and wants
to be correct, but that's hardly a reason to accept that his claims are true
, are they?
there actually is
peer review, please trot it out
. Don't just say
that it's been peer reviewed; back it up
. (again, same caveat about me not having watched the video apply here. But honestly, you've watched the video, and if it does have listing of peer reviewed material or replication of experiments by others, you could always just list them out here for the benefit of everyone, including yourself