DVZ3, here is a suggestion for an alternative form of your "Reason Game" to test reasoning capabilities.
Imagine that the world had a different focus. There are only three (3) groups to join and when you reach adulthood you must choose one. First is the soccer (football to all but Americans) group: fast paced but not violent till personalities clash then the teams and the fans all erupt into violence. Second is the (American) football group: tackle football full of the spectacle of violence and the spectators hide their violent tendencies but let them out when they can corner a rival team's fan in a secluded spot or unintentionally let them out when drunk. Third is the nature group: they enjoy running, swimming, walking in the woods, studying the beauty and wonder of nature, and even cataloging their finds. You can only choose one group - which one do you choose?
If he chooses one of the violence groups: What if the rest of your family was part of the ______ (violent group he did not pick).
If he doesn't pick any group: Well, which is it to be? Hidden violence, group violence, or non-violence and learning?
Soccer = Muslim
American football = Xianity
Nature = atheism, science and reason