Holy crap (so to speak)! A year and a half long discussion on a musicians web site about god? Almost 16,500 posts in one discussion? Frankly, I don't know which one of you are more stubborn.
Very impressive. But please don't invite him over here. I sampled the conversation at various stages and I don't think we could add anything to what you and the other folks there have already said.
Sure sounds like most musicians have at least that part of their head screwed on straight. I assume you are one too (a head-screwed musician, that is).
In any case, it is pretty clear that you can hold your own when confronted with that level of inane belief. So you are certainly a welcome addition to our group.
Hopefully we'll get another doozy soon. Our current crop of believers are relatively calm folks and though they give us a chance to practice our craft, they are not challenging our sensibilities too much. But just wait. As I always say of christians, they got a million of 'em.