So are you positing, with no evidence, of course, that it is possible to have a universe where there is no Catholic god? Where, for example, Allah made the world and Islam is the correct religion?
I hope you realize where this leads......
How do you know that we are not living in that universe right now?
precisely the point. if an infinite amount of universes exist, then every possible configuration has to manifest itself.
You forgot "an infinite amount of times" in your last sentence. The number of possible configurations, while absurdly huge, is still finite. That means that, according to Lukvance, there are infinite Allahs, infinite YHWHs, infinite Zeuses, and so on.
It also means that there is an infinitely large chance that whatever god we worship is the wrong one for our universe
. We have an infinitely small chance of guessing the right god to worship, since we still don't have any evidence as to which god is running the universe we happen to be in. The signs we think are pointing to Brahma are the exact same signs that someone else sees as surefire proof of Allah, or Jehovah or Zeus.
If anyone actually believes in this, they would have to be arrogant in the extreme to think that they somehow happen to have chosen the correct god for their universe. They would have to be very selective in what they consider to be evidence, because they would have to rule out the possibility that they are infinitely wrong. They would have to be--
Lukvance! There you are, we were just talking about you, buddy.....